By now everyone is aware that Covid-19 can cause death,
primarily in people who are over fifty or have health problems such as asthma,
lung disease, diabetes, high blood pressure and other chronic health problems.
To protect ourselves we have been asked to practice physical distancing, wear
face masks, avoid large gatherings, and wash our hands more thoroughly and more
often than any of us have done in our lives.
Yet, there’s another danger that has not been talked about.
It’s called “Deaths of Despair.” According to the Centers of Disease Control
and Prevention (CDC) “Across the United States, more people are dying from
so-called ‘deaths of despair’—suicide, drug and alcohol poisoning, and
alcoholic liver disease—than at any other point in recorded history.”
In 2017, the overall death rate from deaths of despair (45.8
people per 100,000) outpaced lung cancer, stroke and car crashes when adjusting
for age, according to CDC data. That’s an increase of more than 180 percent
In their ground-breaking book, Deaths of Despair, social
scientists Anne Case and Angus Deaton say,
“Deaths of despair have contributed to three years of
consecutive reductions in average life expectancy, making the U.S. the only
wealthy nation in modern times to exhibit such a reversal.”
Published earlier this year the book details the Americans
who are a greatest risk and the underlying causes of the problem.
“For the white working class, today’s America has become
a land of broken families and few prospects. As the college-educated become
healthier and wealthier, adults without a degree are literally dying from pain
Case and Deaton tie the crisis to the weakening position of
labor, the growing power of corporations, and, above all, to a rapacious
health-care sector that redistributes working-class wages into the pockets of
the wealthy. Capitalism, which over two centuries lifted countless people out
of poverty, is now destroying the lives of blue-collar America.
With the coming of Covid-19 deaths of despair may be on the
increase. Nearly 90,000 have died from the virus thus far. Yet, a study by Well
Being Trust, and the Washington, D.C.-based Robert Graham Center for Policy
Studies in Family Medicine and Primary Care, on May 8, 2020 headlined these
startling findings: “The COVID Pandemic Could Lead to 75,000 Additional Deaths
from Alcohol and Drug Misuse and Suicide.”
The report says,
“The collective impact of COVID-19 could be devastating.
Three factors, already at work, include economic failure with massive
unemployment, mandated social isolation for months and possible residual
isolation for years, and uncertainty caused by the sudden emergence of a novel,
previously unknown microbe. The economics of COVID-19 have already caused a
massive jump in unemployment: job loss leading to personal and professional
economic loss across all business sectors. Hourly workers as well as salaried
professionals have been laid off and furloughed indefinitely.”
The report continues with further causes of increased deaths
of despair. “Isolation, whether called social isolation or physical distancing
is leading to loss of social connection and cohesion. No groups over 10, no
cinema (a mainstay of the Great Depression), no sports, no clubs or social
organizations, no church services. Virtual community may not be enough to hold
off the impact of isolation and loneliness. And finally, uncertainty. The
stress of uncertainty has a serious impact on the emergence and worsening of
mental illness. These are unprecedented times, and uncertainty may lead to fear
which may give way to dread.”
The study combined information on deaths of despair from 2018
as a baseline (there were 181,686), projected levels of unemployment from 2020
to 2029 and then estimated the additional annual number of deaths based on
economic modeling. Across nine different scenarios, the additional deaths of
despair range from 27,644 (quick recovery, smallest impact of unemployment on
deaths of despair) to 154,037 (slow recovery, greatest impact of unemployment
on deaths of despair), with 75,000 being the most likely. “When considering the
negative impact of isolation and uncertainty, a higher estimate may be more
accurate,” the study concluded.
As a therapist I tell people that before we can decide what
course of action is best for us, we have to look at both sides of the question.
As we face the decision of when and how to leave our homes and get back to our
lives in the community, we have to look at the risks and rewards of both sides
of the equation.
What are the risks of going back out and mingling with
people and facing an increased risk of getting infected by the virus? What are
the rewards and benefits of getting back to interacting with others and getting
our economy back on its feet? On the other side of the equation we have to ask
what are the benefits of staying close to home and only going out when
absolutely necessary? And what are the risks to staying at home with the
increased pressures and social isolation?
One of the few public figures who is looking at both sides
L. Katz, M.D. Dr. Katz is a board-certified specialist in Preventive
Medicine & Public Health, the founder and former director of Yale
University’s Yale-Griffin Prevention Research Center, Past-President of the
American College of Lifestyle Medicine, and Founder/President of the True
Dr Katz syas,
“From the early going, I have championed total harm
minimization noting that there was more than one way for the combination
of infection and interdiction to hurt and kill people. These weeks (lifetimes?)
into the pandemic response, we have new indications that the indirect death
toll – so-called ‘deaths of despair’ – looks to rival the direct toll of the
In our politically charged atmosphere of fear and division,
its simpler to choose a side—Left or Right, Democrat or Republican, stay at
home or get out in the world. Either/or scenarios may be simpler and may fit
our current state of polarization, but they are bad for our health. We need, as
Dr. Katz recommends, “total harm minimization.”
Part of this approach recognizes the realities of life and
death. No matter what we do we’re not going eliminate harm. Someday we’re all
going to die and each death is a tragedy and loss. On any given day there will
be deaths of people who stay at home and die from drinking, drugs, and suicide.
There will also be people who go back out and mingle and die of heart attacks,
accidents, cancer, flu, and yes, some will die of Covid-19, even some young and
So, what are we to do? Ultimately, we all have to decide
what’s best for us, for those we love, and those we care about. Dr. Katz
reminds us that “more and more data are telling us that Covid-19 is two
completely different diseases in different populations. It is severe and
potentially lethal to the old, the chronically ill and those with pre-existing
conditions. It is, however, rarely life-threatening, often mild — and often
even asymptomatic — among those under 50 or 60 in generally good health.”
Being that I’m 76 years-old, have had chronic asthma, and
lung problems, I’m doing to remain cautious and stay closer to home, maybe for
a long time until we have a workable and safe vaccine. I’ll miss some of the
community life, but I’ll adapt. Most of my neighbors are younger and healthier
and can’t wait to get back out and mingle. No matter how you slice it, we’re in
a new world. For me, I’m listening to those I feel I can trust and making
decisions that make sense to me. As I learn more and my gut feelings change,
I’ll decide accordingly.
I look forward to your comments. If you’d like to read more
of my regular posts visit me here.
This article first appeared on Jed’s blog.
Thanks to Road Trip with Raj for
sharing their work on Unsplash